The Mentor Shortage Is Self-Inflicted

When you work for yourself, nobody assigns you a mentor. Here is how to decide what you need one for, how to recognize the right person, and a six-week routine for finding them beyond the people you already know.

Several early readers of The Accidental Mentee told me the same thing about Chapter 13. They liked the argument, they ran the Tune-Up, and then they hit a wall. The Tune-Up assumes you have at least one mentor to tune. What if the only people you know are clients, former colleagues, and other people selling roughly what you sell?

That is a fair challenge, and it is the usual position for anyone working without an employer. A salaried career hands you a supply of senior people whether you ask for one or not. A freelance or founding career hands you a network shaped almost entirely by who has paid you. The people in it are useful, and many are friends. Very few of them are placed to mentor you.

So this post takes one step back from the chapter. It is about going outside the network you already have, deliberately, to find people worth learning from. It answers three questions in order. What is the search for? How will you know a good candidate when you see one? And what does a workable process look like for someone who also has invoices to send?

Decide What the Search Is For

A search with no stated purpose still ends somewhere. It ends with the most visible person who happens to say yes. Before you look for anyone, decide what you want a mentor outside your circle to do that the people inside it cannot.

For independent workers, five objectives come up again and again. Most people need one or two of them at a time, not all five.

1. Borrow practice you have not yet built. The strongest evidence here comes from founders. In a randomized field experiment with 100 growth-stage technology firms in India, founders were paired at a retreat with a fellow founder for advice. Those matched with a peer who managed people in a structured way (regular meetings, consistent goals, frequent feedback) ran firms that were 28 percent larger two years later, and 10 percentage points less likely to have failed, than those matched with a hands-off peer.[1] The useful lesson is narrower than "advice works." What your adviser actually does in their own business is what travels to yours.

2. Close one specific gap. A study of an incubator in South Africa randomly assigned entrepreneurs to mentors of differing ability. A year on, those with the stronger mentors had about 3 percent more revenue and profit, and the benefit was largest for the entrepreneurs who started with the least knowledge and experience.[2] These are modest numbers from one program, and I would not stretch them far. They do suggest that a mentor earns the most where you know the least, which is an argument for pointing the search at your weakest area and away from your favorite one.

3. See past the edge of your own market. Your existing contacts mostly know what you know. A large experiment on LinkedIn, covering some 20 million members, found that moderately weak ties did more to move people into new jobs than close ones.[3] For a freelancer or founder the equivalent prize is the next sector, the next kind of client, or the pricing model nobody in your current circle uses. That information lives one or two introductions away.

4. Hear from someone with nothing to buy or sell. Chapter 13 makes this case at length, so I will only restate it. Clients, investors, platforms, and fellow freelancers all have a commercial angle on you, however kindly meant. Research on independent workers found that the ones who cope best anchor themselves deliberately to people, among other things, because no organization is doing it for them.[4] A mentor outside your commercial circle is one of the few people to whom you can say "I don't know how to do this" at no cost.

5. Borrow a route map from someone a few steps ahead. A study of New York technology companies found that a third of founders mentored by a successful entrepreneur went on to build top-performing firms, roughly three times the rate for other firms in the sector.[5] That is a correlation, and good founders may simply attract good mentors. Still, it fits older findings that mentors only a step or two ahead give unusually usable help, because they remember the terrain.[6]

One further finding is worth having in your pocket, because it concerns freelancers directly. A survey of 1,874 freelancers across five European countries found that those who networked more actively reported stronger skills, a greater sense of connection, and, through those two, more satisfaction with their careers and better prospects.[7] Reaching outward is part of how an independent career stays healthy. It is not a distraction from the paid work.

Before moving on, write your objective as one sentence: "Over the next six months, I want a mentor who can help me ___." If the blank takes more than a line to fill, you have two objectives, and probably two searches.

Write the Criteria Before You Meet the Charming One

Left to instinct, most of us choose mentors the way we choose restaurants in a strange town: the one with the crowd outside. We go for the well-known name, the confident speaker, the person we happened to like at a conference. None of those is a test of whether they can help with the objective you just wrote down.

Criteria do three practical jobs. They let you compare candidates against the same yardstick, so the likable one does not win by default. They make introductions possible, because "do you know anyone who has taken a consultancy from two people to ten?" gets answers and "do you know any good mentors?" gets a shrug. And they let you turn down a generous offer from the wrong person without guilt.

There is evidence that choosing on purpose pays. In a randomized trial in Togo, entrepreneurs who received a two-hour session on how to approach and work with new acquaintances went on to connect with 50 percent more peers. More of those connections were with people whose skills complemented their own, and monthly profits rose by about 20 percent.[8] The pool of people on offer had not changed. What changed was how well they chose from it.

A second finding stops this from turning into a cold procurement exercise. Across many studies, trust and a sense of similarity are among the strongest predictors of how much support a mentee receives.[9] Put the two findings together and you get a workable rule: look for someone different from you in what they know and similar to you in what they care about.

Readers of the book will recognize the three headings from the Mentor Profile in Chapter 3: relevance, style, and capacity. Those still apply. Independent workers need two more, which I have called distance and independence below.

CriterionThe testA freelancer's versionA founder's version
Relevant, recent experienceHave they done what I am about to do, recently enough to remember how?Moved from day rates to project pricing within the last five yearsTook a product from its first ten customers to its first hundred
Complementary know-howAre they strong where I am weak?I am strong on craft and weak on selling; they are known for winning workI am technical; they have hired and run a sales team
DistanceAre they outside the circle I already draw on?Works in a neighboring sector, and shares none of my clientsNot in my accelerator cohort or my investors' portfolio
IndependenceDo they have nothing to gain commercially from me?Not a client, a prospect, or a rival for the same contractsNot an investor, a supplier, or someone I hope to sell to
StyleWill they tell me what they think?Has a reputation for candor, and asks more than they pronounceComfortable saying "I would not do that," and explaining why
Capacity and inclinationDo they have the time, and do they like doing this?Teaches, writes, or speaks, which suggests they enjoy passing things onHas helped other founders before, and can spare an hour a quarter

Six criteria is too many to hold a real person against. Pick three as must-haves and treat the rest as tie-breakers. Two short examples show how different the result can look.

Elena is a freelance UX researcher, three years in, whose income depends on two agencies. Her objective is to win direct clients. Her must-haves are someone who made that same move in the last five years, who is strong at commercial conversations, and who does not compete for her agencies' work. Seniority and fame do not appear on her list at all.

Marcus runs a six-person software firm and has never managed managers. His objective is to stop being the bottleneck. His must-haves are a founder who has grown a team past thirty, who has no financial interest in his company, and who will be blunt with him. A sector match would be pleasant and is not required.

Notice what the criteria ruled out in both cases: the impressive person who is ten steps ahead, long past remembering what the next step feels like.

Build a Small Process, Then Run It

Inside an organization, meeting senior people happens as a side effect of turning up. Outside one, it happens only if you arrange it. That calls for a process, and the word need not alarm anyone. What follows fits into about half an hour a week for six weeks.

  1. Put the objective and the criteria on one page. You have already done this if you followed the two sections above. Keep the page. You will reuse it.

  2. Build a long list of eight to ten names from several directions. Start with dormant ties: people you once knew and have lost touch with. Research on reconnecting shows these relationships revive more readily than people expect, and they bring news from places your current circle does not reach.[10] Then add second-degree contacts (ask two or three people you trust the specific question your criteria give you), members of a professional body or community of practice, and people whose writing or talks have changed how you work. Leave current clients off the list.

  3. Score the list against your three must-haves and choose four. A simple yes, partly, or no for each is enough. Four is the number to approach, because some will not reply and some will not fit once you have spoken.

  4. Ask for advice on one question, not for mentoring. Send a short message that says who you are, why them in particular, the single question you are working on, and a request for twenty minutes. An example follows this list.

  5. Treat the first conversation as a trial for both of you. Bring the question and your own current answer to it. Listen more than you talk. Before the end, ask, "Who else should I be speaking to about this?" That one question is how a list of ten becomes a list of fifteen.

  6. Report back within two weeks. Tell them what you did with their advice and what happened. This is the step most people skip, and it is the one that turns a favor into a relationship. Where you can, send something useful in return: an article, an introduction, a data point from your own corner of the market.

  7. Let the relationship earn its name. After two or three useful exchanges, suggest a rhythm, such as a conversation each quarter. In the New York study mentioned earlier, the pairs that did best had met at least three times.[5] One good coffee is a good coffee. It takes repetition to make a mentor.

  8. Review twice a year, and whenever your work changes shape. Look at the one-page sheet again. If the objective has moved, the criteria move with it, and the search restarts. This is the same trigger that sets off the Tune-Up in Chapter 13.

Here is the kind of message step 4 has in mind.

Dear Ms. Okafor, I am a freelance UX researcher and have followed your writing on moving from agency work to direct clients. I am attempting the same shift this year and am stuck on one question: how to price a first engagement with a client who has never bought research before. Would you be willing to give me your advice in a twenty-minute call sometime in the next month? I would be glad to work around your schedule.

Three pieces of research explain why a message like this works, and each one answers a fear that independent workers tend to carry.

The fear that you are imposing. Across a series of experiments with more than 2,000 participants, people who needed help consistently underestimated how willing others would be to give it, and how good the helpers would feel afterward.[11] The reluctance sits with the asker far more than with the person asked.

The fear of looking as though you do not know your job. Chapter 13 argues that selling your expertise for a living trains you to hide what you do not know. The evidence points the other way. In experiments run by researchers at Harvard and Wharton, people who asked for advice on a difficult task were judged more competent than those who did not ask, particularly when they asked someone with real expertise in the matter.[12] A well-aimed question signals judgment. The same studies carry a warning: asking an expert about something outside their field undid the effect, which is one more reason to have criteria.

The fear of getting a polite nothing. The wording of the request matters. A field experiment covering more than 27,000 written comments found that people asked for "advice" gave more concrete and usable suggestions than people asked for "feedback," because advice turns attention to what you should do next.[13] So ask what they would do in your position. Avoid asking what they think of your plan.

Expect some attrition. My own rule of thumb, which is experience and not research, is that ten names produce four approaches, two or three conversations, and one relationship worth keeping. That is a good return on six weeks. It also means a single unanswered message tells you nothing about your prospects.

What the Evidence Can and Cannot Carry

A word on how far to trust all this. The founder studies come from programs in India, South Africa, and Togo, and from one city's technology sector. The studies on asking were run largely with American participants in settings far from a freelancer's inbox. Freelancers themselves remain thinly studied. I have joined these findings into a sequence because they point the same way, and the sequence is my construction. No single study tested it.

Start Smaller Than You Think

None of this needs a free month. This week, write the one-sentence objective and three must-haves. Next week, list ten names. The week after, send the first message.

The network you have was built by your work. It reflects who hired you, who sat near you, and who paid on time. The one you need next has to be built by you, and it starts with a single well-aimed question to a stranger who, on the evidence, is more willing to answer than you expect.

Chapter 13 of The Accidental Mentee sets out the Tune-Up for keeping these relationships working once you have them. Chapters 3 and 4 cover the Mentor Profile and how to choose between candidates. More about the book is at corex.net/tam.

Sources

Sources marked (new) do not appear in The Accidental Mentee. The others are cited in the book.

  1. (new) Aaron Chatterji, Solène Delecourt, Sharique Hasan, and Rembrand Koning, "When Does Advice Impact Startup Performance?," Strategic Management Journal 40, no. 3 (2019): 331–56, https://doi.org/10.1002/smj.2987.

  2. (new) Valentina A. Assenova, "Early-Stage Venture Incubation and Mentoring Promote Learning, Scaling, and Profitability Among Disadvantaged Entrepreneurs," Organization Science 31, no. 6 (2020): 1560–78, https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2020.1367.

  3. Karthik Rajkumar et al., "A Causal Test of the Strength of Weak Ties," Science 377, no. 6612 (2022): 1304–10, https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abl4476.

  4. Gianpiero Petriglieri, Susan J. Ashford, and Amy Wrzesniewski, "Agony and Ecstasy in the Gig Economy: Cultivating Holding Environments for Precarious and Personalized Work Identities," Administrative Science Quarterly 64, no. 1 (2019): 124–70, https://doi.org/10.1177/0001839218759646.

  5. (new) Rhett Morris, "Mentors Are the Secret Weapons of Successful Startups," TechCrunch, March 22, 2015, https://techcrunch.com/2015/03/22/mentors-are-the-secret-weapons-of-successful-startups. Reports Endeavor Insight's study of New York technology firms.

  6. Ellen A. Ensher, Craig Thomas, and Susan E. Murphy, "Comparison of Traditional, Step-Ahead, and Peer Mentoring on Protégés' Support, Satisfaction, and Perceptions of Career Success," Journal of Business and Psychology 15, no. 3 (2001): 419–38.

  7. (new) Sofie Jacobs, Ans De Vos, David Stuer, and Beatrice I. J. M. Van der Heijden, "'Knowing Me, Knowing You' the Importance of Networking for Freelancers' Careers: Examining the Mediating Role of Need for Relatedness Fulfillment and Employability-Enhancing Competencies," Frontiers in Psychology 10 (2019): 2055, https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02055.

  8. (new) Stefan Dimitriadis and Rembrand Koning, "Social Skills Improve Business Performance: Evidence from a Randomized Control Trial with Entrepreneurs in Togo," Management Science 68, no. 12 (2022): 8635–57, https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4334.

  9. Rajashi Ghosh, "Antecedents of Mentoring Support: A Meta-Analysis of Individual, Relational, and Structural or Organizational Factors," Journal of Vocational Behavior 84, no. 3 (2014): 367–84, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jvb.2014.02.009.

  10. Emanuela Rondi, Daniel Z. Levin, and Alfredo De Massis, "The Reconnection Process: Mobilizing the Social Capital of Dormant Ties," Organization Science 35, no. 2 (2024): 573–600, https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2023.1685.

  11. (new) Xuan Zhao and Nicholas Epley, "Surprisingly Happy to Have Helped: Underestimating Prosociality Creates a Misplaced Barrier to Asking for Help," Psychological Science 33, no. 10 (2022), https://doi.org/10.1177/09567976221097615.

  12. (new) Alison Wood Brooks, Francesca Gino, and Maurice E. Schweitzer, "Smart People Ask for (My) Advice: Seeking Advice Boosts Perceptions of Competence," Management Science 61, no. 6 (2015): 1421–35, https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2014.2054.

  13. (new) Hayley Blunden et al., "Eliciting Advice Instead of Feedback Improves Developmental Input," Management Science (published online July 22, 2025), https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.03207.

Next
Next

Ghosted by Your Mentor: A Survival Guide